No need to be worried. The reason that there is no concrete answer is that there are many factors that come into play. For example, something as simple as running high octane fuel on a stock engine can cause increased oil consumption over an extended period of time. A *LOT* of the people who have had oil consumption issues are those who have installed AFTERMARKET INTAKE FILTERS that don't properly draw from the crankcase. Even with the newer approach to aftermarket intake filters, the little bits of oil drawn through the crankcase vent will be drawn into the engine and burn unlike with the stock exhaust where those oil droplets will be stopped by the filter and ultimately will flow out the drain.
One of the main things that prevents oil consumption is maintaining a low pressure in the crankcase. Any engine will have some blow-by (exhaust gases escaping past the rings)... there is no way to stop this 100%. Now if the pressure goes up in the crankcase, then more pressure will escape out the vent to the intake and up the rings into the combustion chamber. Both will result in oil getting into the combustion chamber. Oil in the combustion chamber will burn and provide carbon deposits, causing the rings to stick, which leads to more exhaust escaping into the crankcase -- they call this the snowball effect. This is precisely the reason why some people get good results using ringfree or seafoam to clean out their engines.
Sometimes, poor breakin can cause excessive and localized heat which can weaken and/or deform rings -- the wildly popular "motoman" breakin technique can do a great job of killing an engine (what would you expect from a mechanic trying to GENERATE CUSTOMERS?) -- the reason for the popularity of this approach is that you basically throw the breakin to the wind and let it rip before its ready, and everyone wants to let it rip. Yet others have had things go loose in their engines, resulting in abrasive materials attacking the cylinder and rings.
Now about the 05 rings.... they seal better against the cylinder. The result of this better seal is less exhaust gas escaping through the rings resulting in a lower crankcase pressure, and the lower crankcase pressure (and greater seal) preventing oil from being drawn into the combustion chamber during the intake stroke (when the pressure in the combustion chamber is a relative vacuum compared to ambient and crankcase pressure). This helps to prevent the snowball effect, but I have to stress the word "HELPS" as nothing can stop it absolutely. Once it starts, nothing will stop it except for cleaning it out.
The end result... if your machine is well maintained and has stock intake, and if you don't have *bad luck*, then there is no problem with ANY YEAR. The 05+ are somewhat more secure, so unless you are doing something wrong with yours, there is no need to be worried.