Dont like either of those at all...the "vertical look" of them from side throws off all the lines IMO....
I think if its cold and you need taller, the SE window is the only one that offers sexy looks with decent coverage. I am not and never have been a fan of anything painted solid, unless is below the ski tips. It messes up the peripheral vision more then you think, until you jump on a DOO.....Doo was smart in their clear handguards and mostly clear or very low windows, this offers a great sight line when riding....For me, and how we all ride, and my area...I am also sweating butt off so I want low but just enough to tuck behind on the gun.
I grabbed an SE window for coldest days, but will run stocker much of the time.
Dan